Who is the worst person to draft a job description?

Dave (not a real name), a client of mine, once contacted me to ask if I knew someone to fill a position for him. He went on to explain that they have been trying for a while but don’t seem to find the right person. I asked Dave to email me the job description. When I received it, and read it, I realized immediately what the problem was.

I gave Dave a call. The job description outlined the requirements for a technical position. However, knowing my client’s business fairly well, it seemed to me quite overblown. There were items in the description and years of experience that I did not think were necessary to do the job. In fact there were elements in the job description that did not even apply to this client’s particular needs.

I asked Dave who had drafted the job description. He explained that it was Jack, the person whom the new hire would replace. Jack had been in that position for a number of years and is now moving on to a different function in the company.

I have seen this happen many times. When a person is asked to draft a job description for his or her own job, they feel a very strong need to glorify their role. They end up adding so many requirements that it is almost impossible to fill the position by someone else. For the person writing the job description this is just more proof of how difficult it is to do their job and replace them. It is an ego trip. Instead of focusing on what is required to do the ob, they blow their role completely out of proportion to build an image of their own importance.

Get a supervisor to write the job description. Someone who will manage the new hire but who is not being replaced by the new hire. This manager will focus on what he or she is looking for to fill the need and will be more realistic. Furthermore, he or she will not normally have any other motive to distort or exaggerate the requirements for the position.


2 thoughts on “Who is the worst person to draft a job description?

  1. I have observed this happen so often! Hiring manager often shy away from writing or even modifying the JD! Worse, they even dont give good idea to recruiters! Not sure how we could solve this problem. But given that social media is being leveraged to target job explorers (essentially passive job seekers who are open to exploring) a good JD that not only talk about expectation and deliverables but also about benefits of the position better. Your views on the same are welcome!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s